Monhegan MaineRESTAURANTS & PLACES TO EAT
Listed below are some of the best restaurants and places to eat near Monhegan, Maine.
1. The Island Inn Dining Room
CLASSIC COASTAL CUISINE
The Island Inn Dining Room on Monhegan offers a refined menu featuring fresh, local Maine seafood and meats in a charming, historic seaside setting. Guests enjoy stunning harbor views while savoring dishes such as lobster, scallops, and creative vegetarian options. The restaurant is known for its hospitable atmosphere and is open to both inn guests and the public for breakfast and dinner.
2. The Barnacle Café
CASUAL WHARFSIDE EATS
The Barnacle Café is a laid-back spot located near the Monhegan wharf, serving sandwiches, chowder, salads, and baked goods. Visitors can enjoy a quick meal with freshly brewed coffee sourced from local Monhegan Coffee Roasters. Its convenient location and casual fare make it a favorite stop for both locals and day-trippers exploring the island.
3. Monhegan Fish House
FRESH SEAFOOD SHACK
Monhegan Fish House provides some of the freshest seafood on the island, using local catches to prepare classic Maine dishes. Patrons can enjoy a variety of lobster, fish sandwiches, and chowders in a relaxed, waterfront setting. The casual vibe and emphasis on local flavors make it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.
4. Monhegan House Restaurant
FARM-TO-TABLE DINING
Monhegan House Restaurant is celebrated for its 95% scratch kitchen, serving inventive dinner dishes highlighting the best of sea, land, and air. The menu changes nightly, showcasing dishes like halibut, lamb chops, and creative vegetarian fare using seasonal ingredients. With breakfast included for inn guests and dinner open to all, it's a popular spot for both residents and visitors seeking quality cuisine.
5. The Novelty
PIZZA AND SWEETS PARLOR
The Novelty is a cheerful eatery behind Monhegan House, offering fresh pizza, hand-dipped ice cream, and homemade bakery treats throughout the day and evening. Its casual counter-service makes it ideal for a quick bite or a sweet indulgence after exploring the island. The variety and convenience have solidified it as a fun staple for both families and solo travelers.
6. L. Brackett & Son Lobster
TRADITIONAL LOBSTER POUND
L. Brackett & Son Lobster offers a down-to-earth dining experience, serving up classic Maine lobster and shellfish directly on the island. Locals and visitors can enjoy lobster rolls and seafood in an authentic setting, steps from where the daily catch arrives. The relaxed, family-run atmosphere is a hallmark of the Monhegan fishing community.
7. Nite Nite Fattys
LOCAL NIGHTTIME SNACK BAR
Nite Nite Fattys is a quirky late-night snack venue known for its creative comfort food and fun atmosphere. It's a popular after-hours spot for both islanders and visitors craving unconventional bites beyond traditional island fare. The laid-back service and original menu set it apart from other Monhegan eateries.
8. Monhegan Brewing Company
ISLAND BREWERY AND TAPROOM
Monhegan Brewing Company is a family-owned microbrewery crafting small-batch beers inspired by the island's rugged natural beauty. The taproom offers a welcoming environment to sample local brews paired with light snacks and breathtaking views. It has become a favorite gathering spot for beer lovers and visitors looking to relax after a day of hiking or sightseeing.
9. Pemaquid Seafood
WATERFRONT SEAFOOD FAVORITE
Pemaquid Seafood is a renowned seafood shack on the mainland in New Harbor, just a ferry ride from Monhegan. The menu features lobster, fried clams, and fresh fish enjoyed at picnic tables with scenic harbor views. Its proximity to ferry services makes it a convenient and popular stop for travelers to and from Monhegan Island.
10. Shaw's Fish & Lobster Wharf
CLASSIC LOBSTER WHARF
Shaw's Fish & Lobster Wharf is a classic seafood eatery located at the working harbor in New Harbor, offering fresh lobster, steamers, and chowders. Diners can watch lobstermen unload their daily haul while enjoying authentic Maine dishes directly beside the water. The lively maritime setting and quality seafood have made it a longstanding favorite for locals and visitors alike.